The myth about government health care
One common conservative talking point posits that a government-run health care system would lead to a rationing of care, as was suggested in an editorial in Investors Business Daily, which used world-renowned physicist Stephen Hawking as “proof” of their point:
People such as scientist Stephen Hawking wouldn’t have a chance in the U.K., where the National Health Service would say the life of this brilliant man, because of his physical handicaps, is essentially worthless.
The notion that an individual like Stephen Hawking would be deemed worthless under a British-style national health care system is laughable and completely false, but don’t just take my word for it – read what Stephen Hawking himself had to say about government-run health care:
“I wouldn’t be here today if it were not for the NHS,” he said. “I have received a large amount of high-quality treatment without which I would not have survived.”
It’s worth noting individuals diagnosed with Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis typically live 3-5 years after being diagnosed with the disease, and Stephen Hawking has lived 30+ years following his diagnosis, no doubt thanks to the quality health care he has received through the British National Health System.
One Response to The myth about government health care
Leave a Reply Cancel reply
Our Blogroll
- AFSCME Council 24 SEPAC
- Badger Blue, Times Two
- Badger Democracy
- BattiestGrrl Recalls: Putting the 'All' in 'Recall'
- blue cheddar blog
- Blue Collar Blogger
- Brett Cottrell
- Brew City Brawler
- Caffeinated Politics
- City of Contempt – The Scroll of Reason
- Cognitive Dissidence
- Constructive Debate
- Democracy Interactive
- Down With Tyranny!
- Eschaton
- Eye on Wisconsin
- FDLFVR
- Firedoglake
- First Draft
- folkbum’s rambles and rants
- Forward our Motto
- ForwardSeeking
- FoxPolitics.net
- Freak Out Nation
- freshthoughtz
- Grassroots Tosa
- Haas414
- Happy Circumstance
- illusory tenant
- Jake's Economic TA Funhouse
- Labor Chicks
- Left on the Lake
- Left Take
- Letter From Here
- Mildly Relevant
- MisLeading Wisconsin
- Moneyed Politicians
- Monologues of Dissent
- One Wisconsin Now
- Plaisted Writes
- Playground Politics
- Political Heat
- Ramona's Voices
- Red State Progressive
- Sly in the Morning
- South Milwaukee's 4th District
- The Bearded Crank
- The Blue States
- The Chief
- The Lost Albatross
- The Masses
- The Motley Cow
- The Other Side of My Mouth
- The Paul Ryan Watch
- The Plum Line
- The Political Carnival
- The Political Environment
- The Sara Schulz Show
- The World According to Nick
- Turning Over the Rocks
- Uppity Wisconsin
- Urban Milwaukee
- Waukesha Wonk
- Wisconsin Gazette
- WisPolitics.com
Watch the GAB sort through recall petitions LIVE!
Join the Discussion…
- Aaron Rodriguez on It’s Friday! Do You Know Where Your Governor Is?
- Jeff Simpson on It’s Friday! Do You Know Where Your Governor Is?
- Ed Heinzelman on It’s Friday! Do You Know Where Your Governor Is?
- Jeff Simpson on It’s Friday! Do You Know Where Your Governor Is?
- Aaron Rodriguez on It’s Friday! Do You Know Where Your Governor Is?
- Ed Heinzelman on It’s Friday! Do You Know Where Your Governor Is?
- gnarlytrombone on It’s Friday! Do You Know Where Your Governor Is?
- gnarlytrombone on It’s Friday! Do You Know Where Your Governor Is?
- Steve Carlson on The “Cure” for the Susan G. Komen Foundation
- Rich on The Nobel Committee Wants Its Peace Prize Back?
- Aaron Rodriguez on It’s Friday! Do You Know Where Your Governor Is?
- Zach W on It’s Friday! Do You Know Where Your Governor Is?
- gnarlytrombone on The “Cure” for the Susan G. Komen Foundation
- Steve Carlson on It’s Friday! Do You Know Where Your Governor Is?
- Steve Carlson on Meet Scott Walker’s New Criminal Defense Attorneys
Site Login


You’re just picking up this story now? I remember reading about it a few months ago, but whatever.
Again, it’s a Committee of Experts that decides the best course of treatment. Those pesky doctors and patients are left out of the loop; only those with political connections and influence get to call the shots, not us lowly plebs.
And you forget, a guy of considerable fame such as Hawking will always get treated. Forget if there is a priority with someone else needing the limited resource of healthcare.